With my being a Realtor and my wife being a financial planner, we frequently have investment discussions about the best place to invest our after-tax dollars. My wife recently put forward a pretty compelling argument about why a Universal Life policy could be a better long term investment than a downtown condo bringing in $1,500 per month in rent. So, we decided to each make our case and ‘square off’ on the topic.

Here were the rules of the game:

  • A 30 year time horizon 
  • Similar net amount invested 
  • Ignore inflation in order to compare the relative merits of each investment more easily

The case for Investing in Real Estate

For my side of the comparison, I chose a condo in the popular and well-priced Spectrum Development, located right on top of the downtown Costco. Optimistically, a one bedroom unit there will rent for $1,500 per month, and there are units on the market under $450,000 with strata fees of nearly $300 and property taxes at 1,600 annually.

I assumed:

  • Sales price of $438,000 
  • A 20% down payment ($87,600) to avoid CMHC mortgage insurance costs 
  • A mortgage amortized over 25 years at a constant 5% for the life of the mortgage 
  • NO increase in strata fees, property taxes or homeowner’s insurance 
  • NO special assessments • Occupied with a rent paying tenant 100% of the time
  • A small annual investment in maintenance (new carpets, paint, etc) of $1,000 per year.

In Vancouver, we generally accept that making money in real estate means relying on market appreciation, as opposed to cash flowing on the rent. The silver lining to this is that you may write off the loss as an investment loss on your taxes, as opposed to increasing your income (who wants that anyway?).

So, the first big question is: What is a reasonable capital appreciation value to assume over the 30 year time horizon? I looked at Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver statistics for the 20 years between 1992 and 2012, as I couldn’t go back any farther. During that time, the median price of a condo in the same price bracket more than tripled in value. If I extrapolate that over another 10 years, it would be a five-fold increase in value. However, I recognize that the transformation from post-Expo 86 to 2012 has been remarkable, and that next 20 or 30 years are not going to see as dramatic a change because the downtown core is that much more “built out”. So, I assumed a 400% increase in value. With that assumption, my condo would sell for $1,752,000 in 30 years’ time. Not bad, right?

However, the costs of owning a condo are also significant. First, there are property taxes, homeowners insurance, strata fees and regular maintenance that add up to $540/month on top of the mortgage costs of $2,038 (equating to a lifetime interest cost of $260,984). Then upon selling the unit, I would incur a capital gains tax of $328,000 and transaction costs of about $50,000, not to mention my initial cash investment of $87,600. After all is said and done, I calculated a net profit of $712,709.

The case for Insurance

Many people view life insurance as a black hole in which money goes, only to come out when they die. This is no longer the case! Savvy investors, and indeed wealthy individuals and families, have been using life insurance as an investment for generations and recognize it as a powerful means of doubling net worth with each generation.

For those not interested in improving their children’s’ standard of living, Universal Life Insurance is a means of building a nest egg that may be accessed for retirement income, vacations or their children’s’ or grandchildren’s education. Better yet, it is a tax preferred investment vehicle with no minimum withdrawal amount.

Let’s say I was 39 and I took out a $800,000 policy on my own life combined with a $750,000 on the life of my child, aged 4. Insurance on children is cheaper, because they are younger, and it will allow me to build wealth in a portfolio that I can either keep for myself or transfer to my child when she is an adult.

The beauty and unique feature of Universal Life, as opposed to Whole Life insurance is that it is totally flexible. I can increase or decrease premiums as my cash flow allows, within parameters established when the policy is set up, and depending on how and when I want to use the cash value of the account.

I looked at what I could do with a policy using a similar cash outlay to the condo above. David paid $87,600 at the start, followed by 25 years of $12,995 per year. His total net cash investment was about $354,000. I spread the condo down payment over the first 5 years of my policy, and added in the $12,995 for a total of $30,515 for five years, followed by 21 years of premium payments of $12,995 and a final payment of $6,500, equating to the same $354,000.

At a 5% long term investment growth (I am allowed to pick from a variety of funds within the insurance company’s portfolio) I will have $1,411,898 cash surrender value in my account. I can withdraw this as a lump sum, incurring taxes at a preferred rate to net me $831,350. I’m ahead by about $120,000. Alternatively, I can borrow against this and retain the account value, and pay the tab from the death benefit which is over $3.6 million by the time I am 80 years old. Not to mention, if the market does better than the very conservative 5% growth I assumed, then so do I!

Summary

People love, and will continue to love, property as an investment. It is perceived as a safe long term bet. It is tangible, which is a huge psychological plus. We live in a city where property values seem to continualy rise over a five to ten year time horrizon. A property in the downtown core may be a great growth opportunity, with no ‘sweat equity.’ There are other ways of leveraging an investment in property that could work to your advantage. For example, renting out a basement suite until you are ready to grow into it.

However, with a Universal Life policy, everything is simple. You do not need to take ads on Craigslist to rent out your unit, you do not need to respond to emergencies, ensure access for maintenance, renovate, or worry about the housing market when it is time to cash in on your investment. Moreover, you leave a legacy for your family.

If you would like to play with the assumptions on the property investment, or see more details about the insurance illustration, you may download our spreadsheet by clicking here or give one of us a call.

Read full post
Categories:   15% | 15% Tax | 1940 | 2 bedroom | 2-5-10 New Home Warranty Insurance | 4345 Rockridge Road | A realtor that will jump through hoops for you | A Realtor that will pump iron for you | accept offer | accurate pricing | affordable housing | Answers in Real Estate | answers in real real estate | arbutus | Arbutus, Vancouver West Real Estate | art and science of negotiation | arterial roads | Assessed Values Vancouver Real Estate | BC First-Time New Home Buyers' Bonus | BC Home and Garden Highlights | best time to sell a home in vancouver | Better search engine than realtor.ca | Board Statistics | bosa | Brochure | Bubble | building a home in vancouver | Building a new home in Vancouver | Building a new single family home in Vancouver | Building on irregularly irregular shaped lot property vancovuer | Buy a New or Used Home in Vancouver | buy or sell first | buyer's market | buyers | buying a home in Vancouver | buying a single family home in vancouver | buying new construction real estate in vancouver | Buying re-sales vancouver real estate | Cambie | Cambie Listing Vancouver Real Estate | Cambie, Vancouver West Real Estate | Canadians invest in Arizona Real Estate Is now a good time to buy AZ Real Estate | cast in place | changing | changing market | Character merit assessment | Charity Donation | charity donation real estate agent vancouver | Check out my Mobile Search App | checklist for assessing character merit | Chinese Influence on the Vancouver Housing Market | Chinese influence on Vancouver housing market | cigar-et smoke smoking strata bylaws | city of vancouver | Coal Harbour | Coal Harbour, Vancouver West Real Estate | code of conduct | commission | Common mortgage mistakes | Competition and the MLS System | Competition Bureau and the MLS System Changes | condo | Condos | construction cost | correction | cost of construction | cost to build a home in vancouver | Cost to build a single family home in Vancouver | counter offer | CRFS Contingency Reserve Fund Study Vancouver Real Estate | Current housing market conditions in Vancouver, Video Market Update for March 2015 | david | David Setton | davidsetton | December 2011 Market update | declaration | decluttering a westside vancouver home | Depreciation Reports Strata Reports CRF Study Contingency Reserve Fund Study | detached | Directory of Senior's Housing in Vancouver | dishonest real estate agents | Douglas park vancouver neighbourhood | downtown | Downtown VW | Downtown VW, Vancouver West Real Estate | Dubar | Dunbar | Dunbar, Vancouver West Real Estate | Dundarave, West Vancouver Real Estate | East Vancouver | East Vancouver Real Estate | East Vancouver real Estate Market | East Vancouver Single Family Market | empty home tax | ethical | ethics | fairview | Fairview VW | Fairview VW, Vancouver West Real Estate | falling market | False Creek | False Creek, Vancouver West Real Estate | family housing | February 2011 Vancouver Real Estate Market Report | foreign | Four Great Things about Laneway Houses in Vancouver | Fraserview VE, Vancouver East Real Estate | fsr | full price offer | Glenmore, West Vancouver Real Estate | Grandview VE, Vancouver East Real Estate | Green building, Building a green home in Vancouver, Live Green, Environmental Construction | Guildford, North Surrey Real Estate | Hamilton Real Estate | Harbour Green | Heritage Home Renovation | heritage register | home | Home and Garden Show 2011 | Home building in Vancouver | Home buyers guide Vancouver real estate | Home buyers Guide Vancouver Real Estate Purchase | home market | home prices | Home Prices Vancouver | home sales | Home Staging | home values | homebuyer's guide, home buyer handbook, purchasing a new home - the process | homes selling in vancouver | honest real estate agent | Hot to interpret the Vancouver Westside Real Estate Market | housing | How do I find land to build a single family home in Vancouver? | How is the Vancouver Real Estate Board Doing | how to choose a real estate agent | how to hire a realtor | How to make an offer on a home in Vancouver | How to prepare a home for sale | How to purchase a home in Vancouver | how to renovate a home | how to sell a home for money | HPO | importance of floor plan when buying a single family home in Vancouver | Important words to know from CMHC when buying a home | Internet home search | Internet Home Search Tool | inventory | investment strategy | is now a good time to sell a home in vancouver | June Vancouver Real Estate Market Update | Kerrisdale | Kerrisdale, Vancouver West Real Estate | Kitsilano | Kitsilano Home Open House | kitsilano home sales | kitsilano real estate market update | kitsilano sold prices | Kitsilano, Vancouver West Real Estate | know the market | land assembly | laneway houses - cash from your property | Leaky Condos | learn about real estate mortgage options and mortgage insurance | list price | Live Work | lower cost housing | Luxury homes | Luxury marketing brochure | mackenzie heights | MacKenzie Heights, Vancouver West Real Estate | Main, Vancouver East Real Estate | market | market conditions | Market Conditions in East Vancouver | Market Conditions Vancouver Westside | Market Correction | Market Report | Market Report Update from Vancouver Real Estate Board | Market Report Vancouver | market trends | Market Update | marketing | May 2010 Vancouver Market Report | morals | Mortgage advice when buying a home in vancouver | Multiple offers | New Project planned at Oakridge | New vs. old homes Vancouver Real Estate | Newsletter articles | North Vancouver Real Estate | Northlands | number of sales | Oakridge plans | Oakridge redevelopment | Oakridge shopping center | Oakridge shopping Center highrise site | Oakridge Shopping Center plans for redevelopment | Oakridge VW, Vancouver West Real Estate | oakwyn | over asking | Patina Vancouver High Rise YMCA | Pemberton NV, North Vancouver Real Estate | point grey | point grey single family market | portico | predict the market | prefab housing | Preparing your home for sale | price of a home | prices | pricing | Professional Marketing | Professional real estate marketing | property status | Property Transfer Tax | rainscreen | rainscreened buildings vancouver | Real Estate | Real Estate Agent | Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver Market Update | Real Estate Commissions | Real Estate Market | Real estate market update | Real Estate Market Update for January 2014 | real estate tv | Real Estate Vs a Live Insurance Investment | Realtor | Realtor Commissions | recent sales | reject offer | Renderings for New development at Oakridge Vancouver | Renovating a home | Renovating a single family home | Renovation Mistakes | Rescinding a pre-sale condo, Vancouver real estate | rising market | Rockridge | Rockridge, West Vancouver Real Estate | rs-1 | rs-4 | S.W. Marine, Vancouver West Real Estate | Search for Vancouver Real Estate | sell for over asking price | Sell your home faster | Sell your home online | selling | Senior's Housing locations in Vancouver | Senior's Housing Types | September market update | shady realtors | Shaughnessy | Single Family | Single Family home market report for Vancouver West | single family market | single family market report | Single Family Market Update | Single Family Market Update Vancouver Westside | Single Family Real Estate Market | sixteen willows | Sold | sold home | Sold Listings | sold prices | South Cambie, Vancouver West Real Estate | south granville | South Vancouver, Vancouver East Real Estate | south w | south west marine drive | southlands | Southlands Country Fair Sunday Sept. 16th from 10AM to 4PM | Special Levies Contingency Reserve fund Studies | Speculation | Statistics | Stats for the Single Family Vancouver Westside Market | steps to be aware of before buying a home in vancouver | Steveston Village, Richmond Real Estate | Steveston Villlage, Richmond Real Estate | Tempe, North Vancouver Real Estate | The steps involved in purchasing a home in Vancouver | The Value of a REALTOR in Vancouver | things to remember before buying a home | Tips for selling a home during the holiday season | townhome | trg realty | trust | Types of Senior's Housing | understand | Understanding Stats | Understanding the data and stats | update | Ups and Downs of the Vancouver Market | values | Vancouver | Vancouver East Real Estate | Vancouver Housing Report | Vancouver market report | Vancouver market report - september 2011 | Vancouver market report update for October 2011 | Vancouver Market Update | Vancouver Market update report real estate | Vancouver Most Expensive City | Vancouver real estate | vancouver real estate agent | vancouver real estate agents | Vancouver Real Estate Average Priced Home | Vancouver Real Estate Board Market report | Vancouver real estate market report | vancouver real estate market report May 2011 | Vancouver Real Estate Market Update | Vancouver real estate market update report | Vancouver Real Estate Marketing | vancouver realtor | Vancouver Single Family Home sales | Vancouver Single Family Market | Vancouver Single Family Market Report | Vancouver West Condo | Vancouver West Market Report Vancouver BC | Vancouver West Real Estate | Vancouver West Real Estate Market Conditions | Vancouver Westside | vancouver westside market | Vancouver Westside Market Report | Vancouver Westside Real Estate | vancouver westside real estate market update | Vancouver Westside Real Estate Stats | Vancouver Westside Realtor | Vancouver Westside Single Family | Vancouver Westside Single Family Conditions | Vancouver Westside Single Family Home Real Estate Trend Graph | Vancouver Westside Single family market | Vancouver Westside Single Family Market Report for June 2013 | Vancouver Westside Statistics for June 2013 | Vancovour | verona | Victoria VE | video blog | Vnacouver Market Report for February 2012 | well designed condo | West End VW, Vancouver West Real Estate | West Pender Place | west side | West Vancouver Real Estate | Westside | Westside Market Conditions | westside real estate | Westside Real Estate Statistics for May 2013 | What is keeping vancouver real estate prices high | what makes a good real estate agent | what to do before buying a home | What to do if my home leaks | what to look for in a realtor | what to look for when buying a single family home in vancouver | What's Hot and What's Not | what's hot and what's not - vancouver westside real estate | what's selling in point grey | What`s Hot and What`s Not | why invest in a single family home in vancouver westside | Why it is better to use a buyer's agent | Win / Win Conflict Resolution | Yaletown, Vancouver West Real Estate | zoning
The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of either the Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver (REBGV), the Fraser Valley Real Estate Board (FVREB) or the Chilliwack and District Real Estate Board (CADREB). Real estate listings held by participating real estate firms are marked with the MLS® logo and detailed information about the listing includes the name of the listing agent. This representation is based in whole or part on data generated by either the REBGV, the FVREB or the CADREB which assumes no responsibility for its accuracy. The materials contained on this page may not be reproduced without the express written consent of either the REBGV, the FVREB or the CADREB.